Unbranded tubes and a jar of barrier cream next to a folded washcloth and gloves

Zinc Oxide vs Dimethicone vs Petrolatum: Choosing a Barrier Cream for Incontinence Care

November 17, 2026SaveMedical

Quick answer: Zinc oxide, dimethicone and petrolatum are all skin protectant ingredients that sit on the skin and help protect it from moisture. Zinc oxide products tend to be thick and white and take more work to clean off, dimethicone creams are lighter and spread easily, and petrolatum ointments are greasy and can go on clear. Barrier films are a fourth option: a thin, clear coating from a wipe or spray.

If you change briefs for someone every day, the barrier cream aisle can feel like a guessing game. Pastes, creams, ointments, sprays and wipes all promise to protect skin. They work in a similar way, but they feel different, clean off differently and fit into a routine in different ways. Here's how they compare, using what the makers and nursing sources say.

One note first: we're a supplies company, not a medical provider. If the care team has named a product, use that one. This guide is about the everyday choices.

The three main ingredients

The FDA's rules for over-the-counter skin protectants list dimethicone, petrolatum, white petrolatum and zinc oxide among the approved active ingredients (21 CFR 347.10). MedlinePlus says creams or ointments with zinc oxide, lanolin or petrolatum form a protective layer on the skin, and that some sprays or towelettes leave a clear protective film (MedlinePlus: Skin care and incontinence).

A 2021 review of skin care for older adults with incontinence describes barrier products as water repellent and says they commonly contain petrolatum, zinc oxide or dimethicone, and also covers film-forming products. The same review found there wasn't enough evidence to name one barrier product as best (Banharak et al., Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare). So the choice usually comes down to feel, cleanup and what the nurse suggests.

Side-by-side comparison

Type Example we carry Active ingredient (label) Feel Cleanup
Zinc oxide paste Desitin Maximum Strength Original Paste Zinc oxide 40% Very thick, white Most work
Zinc oxide ointment Dynarex Zinc Oxide Ointment Zinc oxide (see label) Thick, white More work
Zinc oxide cream McKesson Skin Protectant Cream Zinc oxide 5% Smoother, spreads more easily Moderate
Dimethicone cream McKesson Thera Dimethicone Body Shield Dimethicone 5% Light, smooth Easy
Petrolatum ointment Baza Clear Moisture Barrier Ointment Petrolatum Greasy, goes on clear Moderate
Barrier film Brava Sting-Free Skin Barrier Wipes, StingFree spray Film-forming (varies) Dries to a thin, clear coat Nothing to wipe off

Strengths come from the product labels as listed on our product pages. "Cleanup" is a general guide, not a test result.

Zinc oxide

Zinc oxide is the white, thick one most people picture. Strengths vary a lot. Our McKesson Skin Protectant Cream lists 5% zinc oxide plus dimethicone and vitamins A, D and E. The Dynarex Zinc Oxide Ointment comes in a 15 oz jar; check the label for its zinc oxide percentage. Desitin Maximum Strength Original Paste is 40%, which our product page notes is the highest level in the Desitin line.

The trade-off is cleanup. A nurse's guide in Wound Essentials notes that zinc oxide can become "caked," which makes it hard to see the skin, and that it can be difficult to remove. The same guide says zinc oxide and paraffin (petrolatum) products can clog incontinence pads and make them less absorbent (Penzer, Best practice when applying topical barrier creams). A thin layer avoids most of that.

Dimethicone

Dimethicone creams are lighter and less sticky than zinc products. Our McKesson Thera Dimethicone Body Shield lists dimethicone 5% in a 4 oz tube, with glycerin, aloe and vitamins in the base.

The Wound Essentials guide notes that dimethicone and paraffin layers need replacing more often, since they can be absorbed into the skin or rub off onto clothing or pads. In practice, that means reapplying after each cleanup.

Petrolatum

Petrolatum ointments are greasy and water repellent. Baza Clear Moisture Barrier Ointment lists petrolatum as its active ingredient and goes on clear, so you can see the skin at each change without wiping it all off. Our product page notes the maker lists it as compatible with chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG) products, which matters in some care settings.

Pastes vs creams vs ointments vs films

The same ingredient can come in different forms, and the form changes how it feels:

  • Cream. A mix of oil and water. MSD Manuals says creams are mostly water with some oil, so they feel light (MSD Manual).
  • Ointment. Mostly oil with very little water. MSD Manuals calls ointments greasy and difficult to wash off.
  • Paste. DermNet describes a paste as a concentrated mix of oil, water and powder (DermNet). It's the thickest of the three.
  • Film. Wipes and sprays that dry to a thin, clear coat. The Wound Essentials guide says some films can last up to 72 hours, and the 2021 review notes films dry quickly on the skin. Options we carry include Brava Sting-Free Skin Barrier Wipes and StingFree Skin Protectant spray.

Ostomy paste is a different product. It's made to fill gaps around a stoma, not to coat skin during brief changes. Our guide to ostomy rings, seals and paste covers those.

How to apply a barrier cream

  1. Clean gently. MedlinePlus suggests mild soap and water or a soap-free cleanser, and notes that some products don't need rinsing. A no-rinse option like McKesson Rinse-Free Perineal Wash saves carrying a basin to the bed.
  2. Pat dry. The 2021 review lists rubbing and scrubbing as things to avoid and recommends gentle blotting. Pay attention to skin folds.
  3. Use a thin layer. The Wound Essentials guide says it's better to apply a little at a time, and to use a layer thin enough that you can still see the skin through it.
  4. Reapply after each cleanup. MedlinePlus says to clean the skin after each episode and put the barrier back on after cleaning and drying.

How to remove it gently

The goal is to clean off what's soiled without scrubbing. The 2021 review points to no-rinse cleansers and gentle blotting instead of rubbing. Wet a soft cloth with cleanser, wipe gently, then blot dry. If you're using a thick zinc paste and it's hard to get off, ask the nurse whether to take it all off at each change or only the soiled part. Switching to a lighter cream or a clear ointment is another option to talk over with them.

For sensitive skin, the Wound Essentials guide suggests avoiding perfumed products where you can. Several of the products above are scented, so check the label.

Where barrier creams fit in a routine

A barrier cream is one step, not the whole routine. Changing soon after a leak, cleaning gently, patting dry and using a product that fits all matter just as much. Our daily skin care routine for incontinence walks through every step, and our incontinence products buyer's guide covers fit and absorbency.

MedlinePlus says to contact the provider if severe skin irritation develops, and notes that incontinence can lead to a yeast infection on the skin. Call the doctor or nurse about skin that stays red, breaks open, bleeds or smells bad.

Frequently asked questions

Is zinc oxide or dimethicone better for incontinence?

Neither is proven better. A 2021 review found there isn't enough evidence to name one barrier product as best. Zinc oxide is thicker and harder to clean off. Dimethicone is lighter and easier to wipe away but needs reapplying more often.

What's the difference between a barrier cream and a barrier ointment?

A cream is mostly water with some oil, so it feels light. An ointment is mostly oil, so it's greasier and takes more effort to wash off.

How thick should barrier cream be?

Thin. Nursing guidance says to use a layer thin enough that the skin still shows through. Thick layers are harder to clean off and can make pads less absorbent.

Do you have to remove all the zinc oxide at each change?

Ask the nurse. Scrubbing off a thick paste means a lot of rubbing, which nursing reviews list as something to avoid. Your care team can tell you what they want for the person you care for.

Can you use barrier cream with adult diapers?

Yes, in a thin layer. Thick zinc oxide or petrolatum layers can clog pads and make them less absorbent, according to nursing guidance.

Browse all our options in skin protection creams.

This guide is general product information, not medical advice. Ask your doctor or nurse which barrier product is right for you or the person you care for.

Shop these at SaveMedical

Free shipping on orders $75+. Not sure which one fits? Email care@savemedical.com.

More articles